What happens when the Trump administration threatens to investigate the very lawmakers trying to investigate it? As Senators Richard Blumenthal and Elizabeth Warren pursue oversight, Corey Brettschneider and John Fugelsang ask whether the new Democratic majority can enforce congressional subpoenas if Trump refuses to cooperate. When the House subpoenaed former White House counsel Don McGahn, it took more than two years to get him to sit for an interview.
Plus, what could Congress uncover about Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick’s family business ties and Nvidia chip export policy? What can lawmakers do when Trump moves to cancel more than $800 million in spending they’ve already approved? And as Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito takes aim at lower-court judges, can Congress count on the courts to act in time? Corey and John also answer listener questions.
Learn more about our sponsor, Americans United for Separation of Church and State, and explore their supporter toolkit: https://www.au.org/supporter-toolkit/
Timestamps: 00:37 – Trump's Administration Threatens Warren and Blumenthal 02:29 – Can the White House Resist Congressional Investigations? 25:41 – Jensen Huang Scandal(s) & Accountability 41:30 – Alito’s Partisan Misdeeds 50:52 – What’s Left of Checks & Balances 53:29 – Listener Mail
Transcript
Automatic transcriptMade by software from the audio, so some words may be misheard. Select a time to play from that point.ShowHide
0:00
Today's episode is brought to you by Americans United for Separation of Church and State. Americans United is here to remind us, regardless of what the front page headlines say, our nation promises everyone the freedom to live as themselves and believe as they choose. And our laws should not allow anyone to use their religious beliefs to harm others. This work takes all of us, and AU needs your support now more than ever.
0:37
Welcome to another episode of the Oath and the Office podcast. I am John Fuglesang, and I'm here to let you know that Donald Trump, the reality TV star and landlord, and Sean Duffy, the reality TV star from MTV's Real World Boston, and Mark Wayne Mullen, the plumber and MMA fighter, assure you all that all flights are in very capable, qualified hands. And by the way, Mullen and Duffy are becoming the celebrity super couple Muffy. Let's go to the star of the Oath in the Office podcast, a man who will never ask you for 50 billion dollars after he grounds all the flights in America. Would you welcome constitutional law professor and the author of the Oath in the Office, Corey Bretschneider. Hello, sir.
1:19
Thanks, John. Hello to you. And I'm very glad to not be directing any flights, on any flights, involved with any flights. Not a great moment.
1:28
Well, Sean Duffy said he needed 50 billion, Corey, but I wrote to him to say America really needs a ballroom first. So I want you to know I'm staying on it.
1:37
Well, it's going to be quite a show, John, because this disaster in the air is a possible symbol of what we're headed for, because as much as we've been celebrating, rightly, the win of the Democratic Party, the fact that there now is a Congress which has the possibility to take our democracy back from a president who's threatening to destroy it. Really, the battle is just beginning. What we've won is the ability to fight. But we're going to talk about how through denying subpoenas, through refusing to spend funds, through investigating the investigators, which we're going to start with, that this president is really going to attack this Congress. And it's going to be it's open to question. whether this Congress is going to fight back. And of course, we're going to be urging members of Congress as we talk about them, talk to them to play the role they need to play to rescue our democracy. So really looking forward to the conversation.
2:29
Yeah, I want to go deep with you about this, because, I mean, as we discussed last week, winning a majority and then exercising the power are two very different things. And these Democrats, right, they now have the votes to investigate and subpoena witnesses. They can demand documents. They can scrutinize any federal spending. They can even, I heard tell in the legends, hold this administration accountable. But what happens when the White House refuses to cooperate or worse, tries to punish them for seeking the truth? The issue isn't really whether Congress has constitutional powers. It's whether those powers mean anything when the president is prepared to resist them and flout the law even more. So here's the deal. Let's start with the ballroom, I guess. Senator Richard Blumenthal, he's seeking records from the donors to Trump's White House ballroom. And, you know, he's trying to find out, like, how did they solicit this money from you to do this? Was anything promised to you in return? Did you have any business interests at all before this administration, before you gave money to tear down the East Wing? And while this is going on, Corey, the DOJ is warning Elizabeth Warren to preserve her records related to investigations that haven't happened yet. And White House counsel Will Scharf has suggested that congressional subpoenas themselves are could get you investigated by the DOJ. So they're not going to just resist oversight. They're going to challenge the legitimacy of any investigations before they even start. What could go wrong? Corey, can Donald Trump criminalize congressional oversight by threatening to investigate the lawmakers who investigate him? I feel like we've seen this movie before.
4:02
You know, we should just start off with a simple fact, which is that one of the most important ideas in our system is the idea that Congress can check the president of the United States. And there are a variety of ways that that can happen. It can happen through legislation. In extreme instances, as we've often talked about, it can happen through impeachment. But the most basic way and an extremely effective way, which we haven't seen for the last two years but we're starting to see now, is investigations. is oversight, as it's often called, by various committees looking into wrongdoing by this administration. So when it comes to the corruption of the ballroom, what we're seeing Senator Blumenthal and others do is to say, who's giving this money? What's the purpose of the money? Are they getting favors in return? What's the incentives here to do so? Is there corruption in the way that the president is raising the money?
4:52
Oh, I'm sure there's not.
4:53
Sure, that's how, yeah, right, shocker. But that's what Congress is supposed to do. Now, this administration, and here's where we get back to the point that I was making when we started, they're not going to give up so easily. And they don't see constitutional government the way it's supposed to work as a allowable. And instead, what they're going to do is to try to continue on with what we've called the self-coup, the attempt to destroy by not listening to court orders, to destroy the judicial branch, and to destroy Congress by not only refusing to comply with investigations and refusing to cooperate. But now here's the thing that we're seeing from the beginning, by essentially declaring war on those who are asking the questions, for just doing their job of asking the questions. Now, the way they're doing it, they can't just say, hey, you can't do that. They need to come up with a way of framing it that might work for the American people to find a kind of legal argument. And so the legal argument that they're pretending to use is the idea that somehow this is a limitation on free speech. This is a kind of McCarthyite committee going after the donors to the president, and we can't let them get away with it.
6:01
Yeah, because of course, if it was free speech, then you've got nothing to worry about because nothing untoward has happened, right? This is the pattern. This is what I've been calling stochastic self-censorship. He's going to try to scare people out of saying things or investigating things. But professor, this administration now is warning members of Congress that investigating the president or his associates could itself be a criminal act, right? I mean, are we entering a period now where the act of congressional oversight is going to be treated as a form of political misconduct? Because I'm sure Fox News is ready for this.
6:37
You know, they really aren't backing down from their attempted self-coup, the attempt to destroy our government. And I think it's continuous with what we saw with the attacks on Letitia James, for instance. She, after all, investigated the president. and his companies, and his family. And what was the response? To try to order his Department of Justice, that doesn't act as a Justice Department, they act as his enforcement arm, and kind of mafia enforcement, as Barbara McQuaid talked to us about, to go after his opponents. And he did that with Letitia James in New York. He did that with James Comey. And that's what he's threatening to do here, to kind of raise bogus cases against, or at least threaten them with these Department of Justice laws. For what? For Congress people like Elizabeth Warren simply doing their job or Senator Blumenthal, as we started with.
7:26
But the White House, I mean, can they legitimately argue that any investigation is criminal simply because it targets the president or people close to him? I mean— That'll fool probably one quarter of white people left in this country. But I mean, that's not going to stand anywhere, is it?
7:43
Well, you know, it's the playbook that they've used again and again, which is the playbook is to just name it. I know you are, but what am I? And every time that Congress says, hey, you're acting potentially in a corrupt way by building this ballroom. I mean, This, of course, is part of the story is that they did so without any authorization by Congress. And now Congress is trying to reclaim its own power by saying, how did this happen? Who's funding it? Exactly. Look into the wrongdoing and what's their response? It's to waive their power, the Department of Justice, and in a thinly veiled way, which is to accuse them of these tactics of going after donors and threatening their free speech. I mean, just to be clear, that is a totally bogus argument. There is no free speech right. to be free from congressional investigations into possible illegal activity.
8:29
Wrongdoing, or corruption. They're not really trying very hard to come up with excuses to break the law.
8:36
They're trying just a little.
8:38
They're just giving up. They're like Trump's immune system. They're just on the couch vaping Washington Kardashians. I feel like I expect a much higher caliber of lie and malfeasance. But, I mean, Corey, what happens when the people being investigated control the entire law enforcement apparatus? could then investigate the investigators. Once again, he's trying to chill Democrats into submission.
9:02
Yeah, and I think here we've just got to pull back from just the story and think about the big picture, which is, look, when we took seventh grade civics or when you take political science one-on-one, what you learn about is the system the way it was intended to work, that we have three separate branches of government who are meant to check one another. Now, here's the reality of where things stand. We have a president who by the way, controls an executive branch that dwarfs either of the other branches in terms of size, in terms of its amount of money that it has to spend. It's just not close. It's just massive, more than 2.2 million people in the executive branch, not counting the military. Neither of the other branches even come close. And yet what he's trying to do is to weaponize all of these aspects of that executive branch, especially the Department of Justice, which is under his control with Todd Blanch, and to use it to destroy what's supposed to be the separation of powers and checks and balances, and to say, no, I don't think so. Come after me, do that constitutional thing, and I'm going to destroy you.
10:04
I mean, he's already done it.
10:05
The question of whether it's going to work or not, I can't say. I wish I could say, hey, you can't do that.
10:10
It'll work.
10:10
I'm going to reassure you, it very well might work.
10:12
It'll work. I mean, if nothing else, he's got that Supreme Court presidential immunity in his back pocket. if he can reach that far. But I mean, so Congress, they can investigate, they can subpoena, they can appropriate money, right? They can exercise oversight. But I mean, this is a situation where a president is going to treat those powers as optional. And he's going to turn any investigation against him into a criminal threat. And he's going to ignore the spending laws. I mean, if a president can make investigating him personally dangerous for members of Congress, because this is what he does. We've discussed it many times. He knows how to do Rich people can do this. He can weaponize the judicial branch in lawsuits against people and essentially bankrupt anyone, like he's trying to do with Letitia James, just bankrupt people to punish them for going after him. We have witnessed this. A chief executive has never abused the courts to drain people's savings accounts so they can stop investigating his crimes. But if he can do this already, hasn't he already effectively created the mechanism for placing himself beyond congressional accountability?
11:13
Well, that's what he's trying to do. But you know what this podcast is about. And I don't want to lose sight of the celebration that we've had over the last couple of weeks because we have elected people whose now job, and this is what they campaigned on, is to hold him to account. And what that requires is, yeah, courage in the face of these threats. And we have seen courage. Think of James Comey, who isn't just facing, by the way, financial pressures, but criminal imprisonment for what? For doing his job, for offending the president. And that's what I believe Senator Blumenthal, Senator Warren, that as these investigations pick up, they're not going to back off. They, I think, have that courage. And they have, of course, their backs are had by the American people who turned out in these large numbers precisely to do this. So, yes, Trump's going to threaten. He's going to up those threats. And they are real. I don't want to make light of it. But this is a moment in which it's important to be courageous. And, you know, it'll go beyond that, too. His supporters, I think, are threatening members of his own party. They'll threaten Democratic members. And that, too, is part of the game of being part of politics in this moment. And, you know, if you're going to do it well, you have to be brave and you have to stand up to those threats. And that's what I think we are seeing from Senator Blumenthal, who, by the way, didn't, you know, receive his threats from the DOJ and say, oh, I'm sorry, I'm not going to investigate the ballroom. He doubled down. He's on the networks, on CNN, on other shows saying, hey, you can't do this. This is our job to fight back, to defend our democracy.
12:43
Maybe the one thing Donald Trump will contribute to this country at the end of the day will be a vast curriculum for law schools. Because, I mean, the president doesn't have any authority to dictate what Congress is allowed to investigate, right? He can't do that. But could this become like a kind of executive immunity in practice, even if no court recognizes such immunity? I mean, he's got a pretty good racket here going. We'll see how much he can scare people. I don't think a lot of these Democrats are going to be scared. But, I mean, could this become a kind of immunity? by fear?
13:14
Well, I mean, immunity has a very specific meaning. It means that the president of the United States himself, this is presidential immunity, can't be indicted for official acts within, you know, within the outer perimeter of his official acts, the way the court puts it. So that is, you know, gives him a kind of get out of jail free card himself, and I think is related to what we're talking about, and that it's incentivizing his power grabs. That's, I always quote Patrick Henry, who says, yeah, if you have a president who's not just bad, but criminal, and they realize they can get away with crimes, they're going to just get bolder until they make that one bold push for the American throne. So that's the relation. But there is a related set of ideas. So for instance, the idea of executive privilege, which is what this president, it's not immunity itself, but it's a cousin of that idea. He's going to say to his top officials, hey, don't comply with those subpoenas. Don't listen. And so as that power push back, you're going to hear a lot of legal arguments. And while some of them are bogus, I worry that when it comes to this Supreme Court, as was the case with immunity, which I also think and thought was bogus, that they might take his side. That's why. This is so dangerous that the civics 101 story is Congress can check a president. Congress can investigate. Congress can have oversight. But the reality of our current moment is you have this enormous executive branch often joined, and I know we'll talk later in the podcast about this, by the Supreme Court.
14:39
Okay, let's party like it's 2019 because you'll remember. The story of Don McGahn, the former White House counsel. We talked about this guy a lot back in the day, but the Democrats subpoenaed Don McGahn and the White House asserted executive privilege and they told him, do not comply. This guy was the White House's lawyer and he blew off a congressional subpoena for two years. I mean, Steve Bannon got in trouble for it. Don McGahn did not. He ultimately agreed to a closed door interview in 2021. Two years later, six months after Trump leaves office, they got away with it. So let's say Democrats are issuing subpoenas all over next year for all this corruption, all these White House officials and advisors and contractors, accountability, yay. What happens when those subpoenas are just summarily blown off, Corey?
15:26
Yeah, the Don McGahn story is, you know, there's always going to be, and this is going to be true as we move forward, despite the congressional victory, there are going to be moments where we're going to have precedents and examples that look like, wow, this really tilts the scales in favor of Donald Trump. And then there'll be other examples, and I'm about to bring one up, that tilt the other way in favor of Congress. So first, on the side of Trump, the McGahn example is really worrying. I mean, just to remind people, Don McGahn was told to fire Mueller. And it's a bizarre story in that Mueller was investigating him. He was ready to resign. He knew his Watergate history. He didn't want to do the equivalent of firing Archibald Cox. The prosecutor was fired by Robert Bork, actually, who was fired for investigating Nixon. So he decided he was going to resign. But then he was convinced, you know what, just show up to work and act like nothing happened. Maybe Trump will forget it. So bizarrely, he shows up to work and just keeps working. Trump never asked him to fire Mueller again. Anyway, Congress wanted to know, like, what the hell was going on with all this interference into the Mueller investigation. They wanted to inquire into all sorts of malfeasance. And as you said, exactly two years of delaying these subpoenas, of litigation, of citing executive privilege, and never a clear win for Congress or for the president, because when Trump, the way it was resolved is when Trump was no longer in power, he made a deal with the Biden administration to give some testimony. So we never found out what the answer to that question was. It's not a good look, when it comes to executive privilege, it looks like the extreme Trump style view, you know, has some thumb on its scale. But now here's the but. There's another case about the subpoena of the taxes of Donald Trump, the Mazers case, where the Supreme Court gives us a way forward of thinking about subpoena power in a way that actually could work. And that's if there's a legislative purpose, then Congress has a lot of power when it comes to subpoenas. So one way forward, and we'll talk about this, is to link the investigations to possible legislation that could do things like get rid of the selling of the office, to enforce the emoluments clause. So all those things we talked about last week and in previous weeks of laws that Congress needs to be thinking about and passing, it actually is directly relevant, not just one day when there's a Democratic president who will sign these laws, But right now, even if the president is going to veto them, because why? Because it gives that subpoena power a lot of oomph and power behind it. Did that make sense, John? That was a lot of work. It did.
18:00
If this White House can just ignore the subpoenas and the DOJ, what if Todd Blanch refuses to prosecute contempt? What power does Congress have to force any compliance here?
18:11
Yeah, I mean, it's a real problem. So even if the Supreme Court upholds the subpoenas? What do we do if they just refuse to, you know, they're found in contempt and they refuse to answer? We start to get into a jumble. And again, you know, I said we'll have some things I'll say in favor of the idea that Congress has real power, real investigative power. And then we also have the power on the other hand of the president. One issue, and a caller on SiriusXM brought this up, so I've been thinking about it, When idea, which is a radical idea, is to return to an idea called inherent contempt, which is an idea that goes back to the late 1920s. That's the last time that it's been used. It's often called the dormant power. And inherent contempt doesn't rely on the Department of Justice prosecuting contempt, which they're not going to do. but it does give Congress the ability to just use its own police force to go out and send people out there. I don't know about this. You know, I think it's a dodgy issue. It's been a long time since it's been used. Another answer is that while this Department of Justice won't enforce contempt, maybe a future Department of Justice will.
19:17
Well, that's a huge comfort to me. That's great. Well, no, I mean, if it's two years to enforce a subpoena and the guy's only in office for another two years... delay sounds like the smartest possible, most convenient form of obstruction.
19:30
They're going to try it. There's other ways to get information. One is, let's just use the ballroom case to go back to it, subpoenas of the individual donors. They don't have any kind of executive privilege to do.
19:40
Yeah, this is what Blumenthal wants to do.
19:42
Yeah. And I think that Senator Blumenthal is exactly right. And what he's doing is he's thinking through, just as we are, these same problems. So if you subpoena White House officials, then Trump is going to say that executive privilege applies and that they can resist and we're in that morass. But there's no executive privilege for the donors. That's very clear. That's it. And I think they would be, you know, in their right minds would say, hey, I better show up and tell the truth.
20:08
You know, my theory on Donald Trump has always been go after his henchmen, go after his flunkies, his his inner circle, his donors, the people who I call it, grab them by the posse. And this is what I've always fought for, Corey. But I mean, when when I heard Blumenthal talk about this and say, you know, not every relevant record here is in the White House, because if these are private entities that are paying for this hideous ballroom. then some of these records are going to be held by private corporations or contractors, right, or law firms. I mean, Congress can go around the White House and get information directly from those parties, can't they? Rather than starting with the White House, it's easier to subpoena a private company than to subpoena a sitting president's senior advisors.
20:48
Yeah, I mean, this Mazers case is a good example of it, where There has to be some reason why you're doing it. And so tying it to legislation, I think, is probably the safest way of doing it. But yes, there isn't that counterreaction of executive privilege that you get. The Mazers case itself was an interesting one because The firm was the firm of the president, so there's some kind of executive privilege attached, even though they're not government officials. That's a puzzle there that isn't a puzzle when it comes to these donors. They definitely do not have executive privilege. They're not working for the president. They're not holding his records or anything like that. I think that's why this is a very clear way to go. I think, too, partly also because they don't work for the president, they're going to be sensible about this and show up when there's a subpoena for information. And that's it. You know, it's part of why this administration is fighting so hard, because I think they see that's what's coming next. And so they're wrongly thinking threatening senators is going to get them out of this.
21:49
Yeah, you're right. And they also know that they're going to be dealing with a lot more whistleblowers and from NVIDIA to the FAA, a lot more headaches and a lot more embarrassing information coming out about what's been going on and what they've known. But Congress, just we wrap this up, Congress can compel donors to this hideous ballroom to disclose information about their contributions and any conversations about possible government treatment that could be favorable, right? I mean, they're going for the quid pro quo. They're going to catch them in a bribe is what this is.
22:18
Yes. And, you know, just to clarify, Congress can't just willy nilly call on people and demand that they testify for no reason. You know, and think of the McCarthy era. That is a real counterexample where you don't want to allow just an out of control Congress to do whatever it wants. But if it's connected to consideration, for instance, of legislation that would pull back on the president's ability to build a ballroom, given that he shouldn't have that power at all, or legislation to enforce the emoluments clause, that's the safest way to do it. Because if there's a legislative purpose, then this kind of oversight is clearly within bounds. And so, yes, I think it's going to work, subpoenaing the contributors to the ballroom.
22:58
I mean, you know, who should the Democrats investigate first is, I guess, the question. I mean, if they have limited time and limited investigative resources then i think yeah targeting the private relationships is the best way to get a bigger fish my question is they're going to have to have this be airtight because you know the white house is going to claim lawfare no matter what they're going to claim they're being persecuted they're going to claim this is punishment blah blah blah so i mean it's going to have to be an investigation that is so legally defensible and so difficult for the administration to dismiss it as mere political retaliation they got to dot all the i's on this right Absolutely.
23:32
And, you know, this job that Congress has now signed up for, and again, which they were elected to do, comes with an obligation to do it well. And that doesn't mean just willy nilly subpoenaing people. You need to know what the reason is. You need to have an agenda of legislative reform that has to be tied to it. And I'll add another thing about good politics, which is, you know, if the American people just see these investigations as Without understanding how it affects them, I think that's a problem. We'll talk about this in the other stories. But I think what's so important is that we see the corruption that the president's being involved in, in affecting the economy, affecting our lives. And that's certainly true in the NVIDIA case and so much else.
24:14
Well, let's take a break and come back and talk about the NVIDIA case, because it's again about following the money with Howard Lutnick and the AI chips. I think the more you get deep into the story, the more the Chinese spy with Jensen Huang is the least interesting, troubling part about the whole thing. We'll be back in just a moment on The Oath and the Office.
24:36
Americans United is here to preserve and protect a promise not fully realized. freedom to believe as you choose so long as you don't harm others. It will take all of us working together across the country to educate our communities about the importance of church-state separation and mobilize people to protect it. That's why Americans United for Separation of Church and State has started their Supporter Toolkit. This document has everything you need, whether you're brand new to grassroots organizing or a seasoned pro, and there's no time like the present to get involved. It's never too late to join the fight to protect our First Amendment freedoms. Learn more and download the toolkit at www.au.org forward slash supporter dash toolkit. That's www.au.org forward slash supporter dash toolkit. Americans United is supporting everyone's right to live as they choose so long as they don't harm others.
25:41
Welcome back to The Oath in the Office. I'm John Fugelsang along with Professor Brett Schneider. Corey, we covered this a lot on my SiriusXM show last week, the NVIDIA story, which started out with Jensen Huang and a Chinese spy. And then we found out that Marco Rubio told Trump he was hooked up with a Chinese spy last May on a plane to China while Jensen Huang was lying. pressuring the president to award more contracts to China while he was dating a Chinese spy. The board was okay about that until it turned out he was dating around in the executive class at his own corporation as well. I mean, all that gossip really distracts from the fact that the government knew what was going on. And for some reason, boy, Howard Lutnick, I thought he looked squeaky clean when he lied about going to Epstein Island, but this is even worse. The New York Times is reporting that Lutnick he was pushing for narrower restrictions on exporting these AI chips that could benefit all these overseas data center operators that just so happened to be doing business with his son's firm. The Commerce Department says he complied with ethics obligations, but I mean, this is already dirty. What should the Congress be looking for to determine whether government policy was shaped by national security concerns or by, you know, private financial interests? Because we know the DOJ is not going to look into this.
26:58
You know, it's so important that, right, that's not going to come from the Department of Justice. This is another area where absolutely it has to come from Congress. And this is a perfect example of what I started to talk about in the last part of the show, which is that we need to find ways when we investigate the corruption of the president and his associates, in which the corruption is clearly linked to the bottom line of what the American people's lives are like. And I can't think of a better example of this. The lack of oversight over NVIDIA. And I should say I'm an NVIDIA shareholder. I'll disclose that. The fact is, though, that by not holding this company to account, by allowing them to run wild at the same time of claiming that there are all sorts of controls, that has hurt the American economy, not just shareholders. It's hurt the entire market. It's going to have impact on unemployment, on the sector of technology as a whole, on inflation, there's just a ripple effect that's going to come from the fact that these people weren't doing their job. And when that is linked to the fact that Howard Letnick has family members, that there's a conflict of interest, that's just a direct example of why corruption isn't just bad in some abstract way, but that it affects the daily lives, the actual lives of the American people.
28:15
Well, I mean, so that's the political problem for Democrats, I guess, because you got the AI chips and the export restrictions and the overseas data centers and national security regulations. Oh, it's so sexy, everything I'm saying, right? I mean, how do you translate this kind of greed and corruption and conflict of interest and maybe bribes into something that voters can understand? Should Democrats be framing all of this, Professor, as a question of whether policy is being written for the public interest or for rich douchebags with connections to the administration?
28:47
Yeah, exactly. I think that stories like this help to illustrate it. In the abstract, how is corruption related to the economy? Okay, that's a hard problem.
28:56
Not really.
28:59
When you see actual examples, sometimes you hear that from people. I mean, I'm thinking of the way that sometimes the current moment is framed. Oh, do we care about people's bottom line, about their pocketbooks, or do we care about the rule of law? And what we're saying here and what we're seeing in this story is, no, it's the same story. And there are some examples, I think, where you show how powerful it is. We saw some people doing that in congressional races. I remember we had the attorney general from New Mexico way back who was talking to us about how to frame things in this way. But I'm going to take us a little outside the United States. In Hungary, the thing that worked in restoring from a true autocracy, restoring a democracy, was showing that Victor Orban's corruption cost the country in a significant way. Now, how did that happen? It was very direct. The corruption was causing all sorts of sanctions from Europe. So when Europe's sanctioning the country, that's why people were suffering, and that idea was able to be brought out. Now, we need to do that in different ways. That's not the exact scenario here, but there is a scenario in which conflicts of interest were causing somebody who's supposed to oversee these companies looking the other way, and that's true of.
30:10
Trump's corruption generally. Yeah, it's a cabinet secretary making decisions that affect a multibillion-dollar industry, right, while members of his family— have financial interests in that same industry. We, the people, deserve a very detailed explanation of how these decisions were made. But, Corey, I hate to say it. I think it's easier to just say he lied to us all about being on Epstein Island. Like, that's probably a better way to get people to care about it. You know, the administration is going to say, well, there's no proof of wrongdoing. You know, they're going to do it all to just say they're being persecuted. But, I mean, congressional oversight is all about asking questions and uncovering facts. They don't wait until someone has established a that they've broken the law, they ask the questions now. And we should be ready for that in the next few months as they begin to investigate. And we see the most powerful, wealthy people in this country claim that this is a form of persecution of them.
31:01
I think that's true of, you know, the New York Times had it weeks ago at $ 2. 2 billion that the president of the United States has used the office to basically rip off the American people and benefit from. And I think we can see it in all sorts of different areas. Think of the bribe plane that you and I have talked about from Qatar. You know, how has that influenced American policy? If you want to talk about the disaster of our economy and inflation, the war, of course, has a lot to do with that. What are the influences on Trump, the corrupt influences that led him to enter into such a foolish war? You know, all of those illegal, in the case of the war, we've talked about why the war itself is illegal, but also corrupt motives have to be investigated. And I think whenever we can, as we can so clearly in this story calls out for it, tie it to the American economy, all the better. That's just a false choice that we're hearing so often from, unfortunately, some members of Congress. Let's focus on the economy, not focus on the rule of law. No, it is one issue.
32:01
Yeah, it's all connected. It's all connected. Well, this brings me to What happens when a president refuses to spend money that Congress has appropriated? Because this thing, this, oh, this stinks like Steve Bannon's hamper. You know, in September, Trump tried to cancel more than $ 800 million in congressionally approved spending just five days before the fiscal year ended. They wanted to cancel the $ 800 million in spending, keep the $ 800 million for something else. Not what Congress set it aside for, and the Government Accountability Office said, Concluded, no, you can't use that maneuver to withhold funds beyond their expiration date. So this raises a lot of questions about one of your favorite topics I've been learning about, the Impoundment Control Act. It's a lot sexier than it sounds, friends. But let me ask you about this. Now, if Congress passes a spending law and the president just refuses to implement it, who has the power to make him obey?
32:55
Well, we faced that crisis, we thought before, and I think the Congress thought it had resolved it. And we faced it, especially in Richard Nixon, when, you know, the bottom line is the executive branch is supposed to execute the law, carry it out. And so when this is just the obvious structure of our government, when funds are allocated, the president is supposed to spend those funds. Richard Nixon often refused to do that if it was for purposes that he didn't agree with. So he would, here's where the word comes from, impound the funds, refuse to spend them. Now, what do you do? One of the things that Congress considered doing was impeaching the president over impoundment. It was one of the issues that they were considering as they considered impeachment. Impeachment, by the way, was never voted on by the full House. Only some articles were voted on in the House Judiciary Committee, but he resigned before we could see those issues play out. But it was on the agenda. And Congress didn't just forget about it. They, in the post-Watergate period, passed this law, this Impoundment Act, that made it clearly illegal to refuse to spend funds. It reinforced the idea that the executive power means carry out the law, execute the law. Now Trump and his team see it very differently. They think, and I'll talk about Russell Vogt in particular in Project 2026, The whole idea for them is that this phrase, I'll just give it to you, in Article 2 of the Constitution that says the executive power is vested in a president. That means to them, the president can decide to spend the money or not. So it doesn't matter if there's an ordinary law that says he has to spend the money, the Impoundment Act. The Constitution and Article 2 give him the power to say no. So that's a complicated way of saying, yeah, they think that they don't have to follow the law. And that's what we can expect more of.
34:43
OK, I'm confused now because this makes me think not of Nixon, but of the fact of Trump's first impeachment in 2019 when Congress had set aside munitions for our ally Ukraine. Because they knew they were going to get invaded by Putin sooner or later. And we all know that Donald Trump tried to blackmail the president of Ukraine by withholding appropriated funds and munitions unless he agreed to lie about Joe Biden and announce a fake investigation on an American cable network. And we all know how accountable he was held for that. I mean, but like a president. A president can't refuse to spend money just because he disagrees with Congress's priorities, right? We can agree on that. He can't refuse to spend it because he disagrees with what Congress wants to spend the money on.
35:28
Well, John, you know, I mentioned this to you before. There is another podcast that pairs a comedian with a constitutional law professor.
35:34
Yeah, and I asked you before to tell me what that podcast is. I'm not going to give the name. I don't want to advertise it. Why do you talk about it?
35:39
I don't want to call them out. Oh, my God.
35:41
Now everyone's going to be Googling to figure that out while they listen to us.
35:44
But my worry is, and I haven't necessarily listened to this podcast, but my worry from some of the framing is that it's meant to be reassuring. And I'm not going to do that because I think that although I can tell you that it's illegal, that he shouldn't be allowed to do it, the reality is that it's going to go to the Supreme Court. And this Supreme Court, unfortunately— has members who love this idea. It's sometimes called the unitary executive. Oh, they do. That Article II vests the.
36:13
Executive power of the president. Some call it having a king, but go.
36:16
On, please. And what's Sam Alito going to say about impoundment? We're going to talk about him later. I'm not too convinced that he's on our side. So this is another place where, although I want to say can't do that, no, there's going to be a battle about Congress spending money and the president refusing to spend it. There'll be court cases about it. Our friends, I'm sure, at Democracy Forward and Other organizations are going to take these cases and we'll report on them and talk about them. And, you know, I have a clear view, but what's the outcome going to be? It's just not clear. And you know what? There is something that can be done because this Congress has the ability to fight back. And you and I have talked about this. One thing it can start to do is to bargain, to use issues where the president of the United States is going to want allocations, but they're going to have to demand allocations that their own funds are spent in order to receive them. That kind of political jockeying is maybe even more important than what's going to happen in the court.
37:14
I'm still shocked at how funny it is that you said maybe Alito is not on our side. I'm sorry.
37:20
Wait till we get to that part of the show.
37:21
We're going to talk about Alito, yeah. Why would you think all he wants to do is sit around and bite the heads off of live screaming angels while telling glorious tales of the Confederacy? What's wrong with this guy?
37:31
All right.
37:32
I want to get off of this, but I just have to say, suppose Congress passes a law requiring that money be made available for a particular program. The president refuses to carry it out. That's our hypothetical. Knowing the DOJ doesn't care and the Supreme Court can't be counted on, what are Congress's realistic options to make sure the funds are spent as Congress distributed? I mean, can they sue the administration? Who would have standing? Can they use future appropriation bills to blackmail them into compliance? I mean, which one of these?
38:00
Yeah, I'm all of the above. I mean, that's why as much as there's talk about we need to cooperate with this administration, the reality is it's going to be a battle on thing after thing. And although one of the main powers of Congress is to allocate funds, it has to fight to make that ability, that power meaningful. Because if the president just refuses to spend funds that are allocated, it undermines that power. So what can you do? Congress itself can sue the president. That's one option to try to get standing and to sue when he refuses to spend the money. Those who are recipients and are harmed by his refusal to potential recipients, intended recipients who refuses to spend the money, they can probably bring those kind of cases. Those are the type of clients that Democracy Forward, among others, finds. But that second, that last thing that you mentioned, I just think that's really the most important thing, that they have to see that any allocation of money has to come with a demand, that the money allocated for purposes, even if the president doesn't like it, that they're spent too.
39:00
That's the thing.
39:02
What do you think, for instance, of the FAA? Yeah, that money needs to be spent and the money that's allocated needs to be used for the purposes that the president gives.
39:10
Just kind of seems like, you know, this is sort of where I come to pretend I go to law school and cheat off your paper. And it seems like the power of the purse means absolutely nothing if a president can essentially decide which laws that Congress passed he feels like carrying out. I mean, the president has veto power now over laws passed by Congress. Deliberate refusal to implement a spending law. That's grounds for impeachment, right?
39:35
I think it is. You know, look at the Nixon example where they used impeachment. But we're not in exactly the same position that we were during Nixon. We have this legislation that was passed to prevent this. So that can be used in court. And I don't want to say in any way that that's not going to work just because Sam Alito is in the Supreme Court. We've seen lower courts often, not enough, take sides against the president of the United States. And this is an example where I think that argument that you just made is going to be convincing to a lot of judges. Namely, if we allow him to decide what to spend or whatnot, how do we live in a democracy? We just have a king who's able to willy-nilly do what he wants. The same is true. It's a different issue. But tariffs, just saying, oh, I'm going to impose tariffs willy-nilly where I want. I don't think so. That's not how taxation works. No taxation without representation means that power is going to be Congress. So that's an example where the courts did push back. And I do think there's a good chance that'll happen here. But the reason to really have hope, too, though, is this ability of Congress to get on the ball and realize that any allocation has to come with demands, demands that the money be spent. So that's a political check, not one from the courts. And I think it's one that will prove effective.
40:46
I think you're right. I just want to say of all types of fascists, my least favorite are the willy nilly kinds. Oh, well, all right. I really want to talk to you about Alito, because honestly. As much as I want to see him out of the Supreme Court, it's fascinating watching this Confederate fan club president fall apart mentally in public. So let's take a quick break and let's come back and talk about, well, Alito's warning about all those lower courts that are, you know, defending the law against Donald Trump. He don't like that. We'll be right back on The Oath in the Office. Welcome back to The Oath in the Office. I'm John Fuglesang along with Professor Corey Bretschneider. So, Corey, let's talk about Justice Alito, my favorite subject. He recently criticized lower court judges for what he described as abuses of judicial power because they blocked Trump administration policies that went against the law. essentially abusing their authority by blocking this president. And he also made sure to warn that Democrats might be using their congressional funding powers to pressure the Supreme Court. What do you make of these comments, Corey, particularly at a moment when the judiciary may be called upon to resolve major disputes between Congress and this president and that law?
42:09
Well, it really encapsulates the theme of this episode, which is that we had a blue tsunami. It's a moment to check the president, an extremely important one. But it really is not the end. It's the beginning of a battle between congressional power trying to reclaim these powers that have been abandoned, essentially, for the past couple of years, and a president who's going to try to continue to evade and even shut down Congress. So now where does the Supreme Court fit into this? Well, this is not a good moment, because what Sam Alito seems to be saying is these lower courts that are doing their job of enforcing the law are somehow, you know, doing something inappropriate. And He's really just putting his hand on the scale of this administration and threatening his fellow judges and saying, you know, I don't like what you're doing and doing it without regard to the facts, which is, you know, completely offensive. And again, speaking out of turn, I mentioned that some of the story in a previous episode, but I just have to say why I find him particularly an offensive person. I met him.
43:11
Please, because you've hung out with him more than me.
43:14
I didn't hang out with him, but I did meet him. And we had a conversation. In fact, I said, you know, I think I'd like to invite you to Brown and, you know, we can have a dialogue and a debate and we'll have you give a lecture. And he jokingly said, well, wait till you hear my speech. This was at the Federalist Society when I was debating a conservative judge. in the days before Trump.
43:35
How was the speech? Was it in German? How was it?
43:38
The speech was an attack on President Obama for criticizing, daring to criticize Citizens United, the famous case, of course, that opened the floodgates of money into politics. wrongly saying that there's a free speech right for corporations to spend independent expenditures at will. And, you know, I listened to this and as it was just a complete, it could have been a political speech by, you know, any of the Republicans running in this election, just an attack on Obama, very defensive, not about the law. nothing that you would expect from a judge. And so I, of course, never approached him afterwards. And I thought, there's no way I'm inviting this guy to Brown. It's a hack.
44:16
I mean, can you imagine a Supreme Court judge? Yeah, he's such, I mean, is he suggesting that lower court judges need to be more deferential to Donald Trump? Because I didn't hear this kind of talk when a black guy was president, Corey.
44:30
I mean, I think it's so obviously partisan just in the way that his attack on Obama was partisan. And, you know, it's not fair that the lower courts are stopping Trump. Well, what issue? The terrorist case? You know, what what are you talking about? And it just raises the suspicion that the Supreme Court is putting its hand on the scales to help this administration without regard to the law. And, you know, maybe there are still other justices that are more sensible, but this is just essentially giving up and saying, oh, it's all politics.
45:02
Yes, Corey, there are other judges that are more sensible. Let me, I probably know a bunch of them. But I mean, this guy warning about congressional funding, that tells me that he views Congress's oversight of the judiciary as a potential threat. And he's signaling that to the minions.
45:20
You know, I think that's right. He's worried about court reform, about adding justices. And oddly, the way he's doubling down on just attacking the lower courts essentially for doing their job is just sending a message that in many ways, You know, I am hearing several academics use this phrase, which is a nice way to put it, that this Supreme Court and certainly this justice are not acting as a court or as a judge or justice. He's acting as a partisan actor. And the more that becomes clear, the more the case becomes even clearer for why we need laws that would expand the Supreme Court and that we would essentially dilute justices votes like Alito.
46:00
Thank you. Yes, expanding the Supreme Court is going to become a litmus test really soon, I think. I mean, if the Supreme Court sides with the administration, Professor, does Congress have any meaningful alternative? Or would that essentially end the ability of Congress for the first time in our country's history to investigate the executive branch in the most consequential of cases?
46:20
Well, I mean, it would depend on what, you know, there are always the answer is there's always a follow up. And each of these branches is supposed to be equal. And although sometimes this court acts as if it's the Supreme branch, that it's the most important one, that's just not how things work. And so, yes, if the Supreme Court doesn't enforce a subpoena, well, subpoena somebody else. if the Supreme Court somehow disallows an investigation because there's not a legislative purpose, well, then put a legislative purpose together with the investigation. I think there are things that Congress can do, by the way, to not run afoul of the Supreme Court, and that's why I've been stressing this idea so often that the investigation's have to be tied to laws. That's just a win on all factors. It pushes out the idea that the Supreme Court is going to stop these investigations. And it also is sensible in that we need legislation to make sure that this malfeasance doesn't continue to happen. Right.
47:13
But that's the thing. What legitimate authority does Congress have over the Supreme Court's budget?
47:19
No. Well, he indicated something about turning the lights off and the same way they allocate funds to the executive branch, they allocate it to the courts. I don't really see that happening. I don't really want to turn the Supreme Court's lights off. I think there are more effective ways to go about it.
47:35
I'd rather turn cameras on. I'd rather turn cameras on in the Supreme Court than turn the lights off. Yeah, right.
47:40
We need more light, more transparency, not less.
47:43
So I mean- I'm just gobsmacked because we've talked so much about how– on this show about how the Supreme Court's legitimacy depends on being seen as an independent institution rather than an ally of this reality show racist clown. Alito doesn't really care about legitimacy, does he? Alito is just so in the cult that I don't even know what to say. The guy has just gone to Scalia land. He doesn't care.
48:05
Yeah, I mean– You know, I think I've said before, I'm at the early stages of this, but one thing I'm writing about is how these justices didn't just come from nowhere. Alito was in the executive branch during the Reagan administration when a lot of the ideas of the unitary executive were developed. And so when you hear Russell Vogt, who's giving a kind of crude version of those arguments, saying, you know, we don't have to spend money that Congress allocates, that idea of the presidency is one that Alito isn't just sympathetic to, but really he was around when it was created. And, you know, that Mies Justice Department came up with all of these ideas that the court is now using to empower, unfortunately, a president who would destroy democracy. I think, by the way, when they came up with these ideas, they had Reagan in mind, not Trump. But look at how those ideas so quickly have been abused. And, you know, that Reagan was a saint. Iran-Contra, I think, was a you know, a serious precursor to a lot of what we're seeing.
49:04
They were both dopey celebrities who weren't that bright, but were good on camera and didn't much care for laws. I could go on with comparisons. But yeah, last point on this. This White House is going to portray any investigations as revenge, lawfare, harassment, persecution, try to overturn the results. There's really a danger, though, Corey, that these Democrats could spend the next two years investigating this guy and holding hearings and gathering evidence and issuing subpoenas and then find out they have no ability to force the administration to answer or even pay attention. I mean, how do these Democrats stop this administration from turning legitimate oversight into a partisan theater spectacle? I mean, they're going to have to be really tight on the kinds of scandals they choose to pursue.
49:49
Well, you know, this is a lot of summing up of themes that we've pulled out from various stories. But one is corruption, I think, is something that doesn't read as partisan. If you can really show it and you can show its impact, especially on people economically, That's a way of squaring that circle, that it doesn't just look like an attack. And, you know, although ideas like the rule of law matter, when you can show that it affects somebody's pocketbook, then that's something they're going to care about. But I also don't want to, you know, as much as I, again, I'm thrilled by this victory. I'm glad that there was not a fight for two years. Congress had really handed over all the power to the president. And to the degree that the lower courts, not as much the Supreme Court, were trying to stop him, he was starting to just defy judicial orders. So now we have, you know, a major branch pushing back against the president in a position to do so. But I also don't want to overstate the case, as your remarks make clear. It's not clear how this story ends. And this is just the beginning, not the end. That's what we'll talk about on this podcast, the ongoing battle of Congress versus the president.
50:52
OK, but I'm sorry, I want to get off on this. We have some listener mail I want to get to. But my last question about all of this, Mishigas, I've learned so much from you, Corey, and it seems like it's all being dismantled. If the president controls the Justice Department and if Congress can't enforce any subpoenas, at least for two years, and the Supreme Court is signaling they don't want to intervene, is there anything left of America's system of checks and balances?
51:17
Well, look, I don't want to undersell what you said. It is an enormous obstacle. The fact that the Department of Justice, when the framers thought about all this system, they thought the Department of Justice, OK, it's not the attorney general. They had this option of making the attorney general independently elected. That's what New York had done and still done. But they subsumed it within the executive branch. And naively, they thought, Well, that person's going to still be a person who enforces the law, even though they work for the president. Well, the anti-federalists, the people who didn't like the system, people like Patrick Henry said, I don't think so, because who's going to prosecute the president when the president does something wrong if the person who's supposed to do the prosecution works for the president? And that will lead a president to get bolder and bolder in his crimes until they destroy democracy. And Congress is not going to have the power if the court won't back Congress up. And if the attorney general is the one that's supposed to, you know, as you said, to bring these cases of contempt. So these aren't minor problems. That's the world that we're in. And it's why all the discussion about self-coup, about destruction of democracy, Todd Blanch is the reality that makes that still a threat. But it's not that you can't do anything. And these brave senators who are fighting back, who are going to subpoena not members of the administration so much as members of the donors. And that's just one example of being creative, getting around it, advertising it, holding hearings, doing fact finding that doesn't necessarily involve these witnesses that won't show up. You can get other witnesses as you build your case. It's not in a court of law, but it is in Congress. It has to be tied to legislative purpose. And I don't want to, you know, we talked last week about impeaching Hegseth. The unfortunate reality, which we haven't discussed yet, but I'll just mention is that some Democratic members of Congress for some reason didn't show up to that vote. It's not happening now. Might it happen in the future? Well, that is an other power to demand information, to reveal the truth. And we might see some combination of oversight and impeachment of executive officials. But one thing is for sure, it can't just be cooperation. This is going to be a conflict between two branches of government.
53:29
All right. We have some letters from our very attractive listeners. Are you up for reading your It relates to everything here. How specifically would reversing or narrowing presidential immunity work? Congress would pass a law, but would the Supreme Court then decide if it is constitutional? We have heard a number of folks say this Democratic Congress among the legislation they got to pass is, hey, let's remind history. We don't want a king. And if presidents commit a crime, they are citizens. Bill Clinton found this out the hard way, but then the Supreme Court changed their minds for this guy. I mean, it's a great question. How would reversing this immunity work?
54:08
It is a great question. We talked some about this kind of legislation on the last episode, and there was a substack about it. I should say these two questions come from the Oath in the Office substack. So you're welcome to write to me at cory.brettschneider at gmail.com or comment on substack and we'll answer these questions. By the way, we haven't said subscribe. Please subscribe, not just to the substack, but to wherever you're listening to this episode. or if you're watching us on YouTube, subscribe there. So let's get into it. It is a great question. How would this actually work? So one really interesting proposal was brought up by Senator Whitehouse, and he's now going to be the chairman of the Judiciary Committee. So it is an example of where this podcast is.
54:49
See what doing this show does for your career? It's crazy.
54:52
Well, see, I mean, this is not just some guy with an idea saying, you know, there ought to be a law. It's like the guy who actually might be able to get this legislation passed. Anyway, what I talked about with him and you, John, was just to remind listeners, was the idea of not necessarily one way to go about it would just be to say the Supreme Court, you're wrong, reverse the case. And we saw what we talked about last week is that Justice Sotomayor was indicating maybe the court has realized it made a mistake and will reverse itself. But what White House's suggestion is, is I think a subtle, interesting way to do it, It's to narrow the kinds of immunity that a president has. So not to get rid of all of it, but to allow, say, when it comes to military decisions, immunity, but to wipe it out in other ways. And what that would do would tee up the issue to the Supreme Court. So if they saw a presidential immunity issue again, they might consider the fact that there's legislation to narrow it. And courts often defer to Congress. That's just a general principle. And I think they also, hopefully, five of them have realized that this broad immunity that they allowed for, for official duty more generally, that that was a mistake. And narrowing it might give them a way out rather than reverse.
56:08
That does make sense. It's going to be awfully tricky narrowing. Did the president... lie about war decisions or release war decisions so people could bet on the stock market. Like there's going to be a lot. I mean, where do we even begin? Good Lord. And the whole time, this guy's arteries are going to do what the good Lord wants his arteries to do. Charlie writes to us and he asks, how can we get rid of these awful people on the court? Note, I don't say, can we get rid of? Charlie says they reject the constitution. Do they not? Can we disbar some like Roberts and Thomas or one or two others? or greatly expand the court. I mean, into the 20s. I don't see it happening into the 20s, but 13 seems to be the magic number that my smartest friends are talking about. What do you think? I mean, what would it take to impeach a member of the court? I think if Clarence Thomas's wife can be part of a plot to overthrow the goddamn government and cops are beaten for a lie and nobody cares, I kind of don't know how much more you need than that. But what do you think, Corey? Clarence Thomas wouldn't even recuse himself from that case.
57:11
Well, I think we should go through the options. And the first one to talk about is the most clear constitutional way to remove a justice and the most straightforward way is impeachment. And the rules follow the same as presidential impeachment. Fifty percent of the House and two thirds. The Senate holds a kind of trial, not a judicial trial, where they'll look at whether or not that justice committed high crimes and misdemeanors. And some of the accusations, certainly of Clarence Thomas's corruption, mean that, yeah, maybe it's time to look at him for impeachment. I think that is something that has to be discussed. There was an impeachment of Samuel Chase, which he survived early on in the Republican And even though he survived the impeachment, it's often seen as a moment where he backed off the most extreme of his positions. He was basically attacking political opponents, lobbying for the Sedition Act to shut down the Democratic-Republican Party. And he stopped being as bad, even though impeachment failed. Abe Fortas was threatened with impeachment and resigned. That's another example of where impeachment was effective. So I think we have to talk about impeaching not just Pete Hegseth, but possibly Clarence Thomas.
58:19
Say it slower. Nice.
58:22
The other thing that comes up in this great question is what I mentioned earlier in the episode, which is what about a kind of court reform that would involve changing the makeup of the court? And there are a variety of proposals that we should talk about. One is demoting some Supreme Court justices to the Court of Appeals and promoting some Court of Appeals justices. That's one proposal that's out there. And another, the most famous, which was threatened by FDR, although not actually carried out by him, would be that Congress would pass a law expanding the number of justices, as John suggested, maybe to 13. And then we would keep nominating and confirming justices. Now, that's not going to happen with this president, but it might happen with a future president. I think the court has gotten so off the rails when it comes to constitutional protection. And Lee words, I think, you know, help us to see that. I think these are on the table.
59:16
I mean, FDR, you know, I always was taught that there were a few justices that were trying to that were really just trying to undo the New Deal. And when Roosevelt had his threat to add more justices, he also wanted a policy where every judge over 70. would share the same seat and they would all vote for how that one Supreme Court seat would vote and it would adjudicate any case. Like over 70, you're in this little pool over here for one vote. You guys vote to see who gets the one. I mean, he had a lot of conditions there. And my understanding always was he didn't try to pass it. He did this to push back and they backed down and they left the New Deal alone. And that was why I kept wishing Joe Biden... would just try to do it. Just, I mean, just punch the bully in the face so he'll stop taking your lunch money for one day. Just try to cow them a little bit into some kind of respect.
1:00:07
There's a phrase that constitutional scholars use to describe what happened, just as you suggested, which is the switch in time that saved nine. So you had these justices striking down the New Deal and which was enormously popular and necessary in the Great Depression. And yet here these justices are saying it's unconstitutional. Congress can't pass these laws. FDR threatens a number of things, including expanding the court, packing the court, and they back off. So I think the dominant for a long time idea was it worked. But there's another part to this that is less understood that I'm going to emphasize. And it's we always want to end with hope. And this is a good hope, which is the midterm election actually around that time was an enormous victory for the Democratic Party and in favor of the New Deal. So what's quite possible is it was not so much the threat to pack the court as the power of the people rising up and saying, we want these laws. Well, that's what we've just seen. And let's hope that the court takes notice of it.
1:01:07
Professor, we covered a lot of ground today. And I thank you for being so generous with your time and expertise. Corey, what is the best way for our listeners to follow you the other six days of the week and keep track of all your doings?
1:01:19
Well, you can find me on Blue Sky at Democracy Prof. I'm still on X at Brett Schneider C. You can find me on Facebook if you want. But I would just ask you again to push that subscribe. If you're listening to us, you can watch us anywhere. Listen to us anywhere you get your podcasts. Watch us on YouTube. I also want to mention, too, John, that there are now, if you want to just log right into the web and not use an app, you can go to theoathandtheoffice.com. And you'll find us there or at corybretschneider.com. And each episode is there. There are taglines. John, some of your smart things that you say every week are there. And you can find also links to the sub stack and YouTube, but it's all on the oath in the office dot com or Corey Bretschneider dot com. So push that subscribe. And thanks so much, John, for this great discussion, as always. And what a great moment for the country.
1:02:12
Seriously, it's crazy. And I hope your flight takes off someday, Corey. I want to just say I'm on Sirius XM Progress five days a week, 12 noon Eastern, 9 a.m. Pacific. We're a three-hour show. Corey's there live every Monday. So if you want to talk to the professor, he will be taking your calls on Monday at Progress. Also, my show, If You Don't Have Sirius XM, is available as a free podcast, the John Fuglesang Podcast. My award-winning book is The Separation of Church and Hate. That's on sale now. And my next book, is available for pre-order. It's coming out just in time for Easter. It is called Fake Christians, a biblically correct guide to breaking the grip of holy hypocrites, gospel grifters, and theocratic thugs. Look for that blaspheming at a bookstore near you come this Easter. And Corey, once again, I want to thank you. I want to thank Beowulf and Wendy and all the wonderful professionals who help slap this show together every week. And thank you, Professor. I learned a lot today.
1:03:03
What a pleasure, John. Look forward to more.
1:03:05
We'll see you all next time on The Oath and the Office.
Can the Trump Administration Silence Congressional Investigations?
Last week, Senators Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) and Richard Blumenthal (D-CT), alongside Representative Robert Garcia (D-CA), announced a plan to investigate major donors to Trump’s “vanity projects.” Will Scharf, White House Counsel, had previously warned in a